Keystone XL opponents grasp at straws in latest stunt

Keystone XL opponents’ climate claims have been repeatedly debunked by the Obama administration, research institutions, and energy and climate experts, yet they haven’t given up.

Today, the anti-Keystone XL group, Friends of the Earth, submitted a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request to the State Department asking it to hand over all the documents related to its reassessment in its Final Environmental Impact Statement of the number of fatalities that would occur if Keystone XL isn’t approved.  In explaining its motives for this latest stunt, Friends of the Earth complains that State revised the numbers on rail fatalities “while neglecting numbers that show how Keystone XL would catalyze an increase in emissions.”

What this actually shows is that the State Department is more than willing to revise its data if it finds a genuine mistake.  As the State Department’s Errata Sheet on the rail fatality revisions clearly explains, State researchers discovered that they had incorrectly queried the Federal Railroad Administration’s (FRA) online safety database, resulting in an underreporting of injury and fatality incidents. Therefore, they corrected the error.  On the other hand, Keystone XL opponents have failed to bring forth any evidence that would legitimately contradict what the State Department – after nearly six years of studying the pipeline – has found on greenhouse gas emissions.

We can’t help but note that this isn’t the first time Friends of the Earth has tried something like this. As Politico rightly reported, Friends of the Earth is one of the groups that led the charge on Keystone XL opponents’ previous “conflict of interest” stunt.  Just as a refresher: when opponents originally complained that there was a “conflict of interest” in the State Department’s environmental assessment two years ago, the Office of Inspector General looked into their claims and found, as Politico reported in February 2012, “There is no evidence of conflict of interest or bias in the State Department’s review of TransCanada’s proposed Keystone XL pipeline, the department’s inspector general has found.”  But opponents didn’t give up – they renewed their calls for an investigation last year so the Inspector General’s Office looked into it again.  In February of 2014, they released a report finding that the State Department “substantially followed” guidelines, the “conflict of interest review was effective,” and “the review’s conclusions were reasonable.” Politico put it best when it reported that the IG’s report “marks yet another defeat for the pipeline’s opponents.” Greenwire called it “a notable blow.”

After these “notable blow[s],” Keystone XL opponents continue to grasp for straws. But no matter how many stunts they pull, they won’t be able to change the fact that Keystone XL passes the president’s climate test – and with flying colors.

DiCaprio’s Eco-Hypocrisy Comes to Canada

The list of celebrities who claim to be environmental activists, but don’t exactly practice what they preach, is a pretty long.  And almost all of them have flown their private jets up to Alberta to tell Americans we don’t need Keystone XL (or fossil fuels for that matter).  That’s exactly what happened this week when [...]

Keystone XL opponents grasp at straws in latest stunt

Keystone XL opponents’ climate claims have been repeatedly debunked by the Obama administration, research institutions, and energy and climate experts, yet they haven’t given up. Today, the anti-Keystone XL group, Friends of the Earth, submitted a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request to the State Department asking it to hand over all the documents related [...]

As Americans Say Yes to Keystone XL Opponents Recycle Old Stunts

Support across the country for the Keystone XL pipeline is overwhelming. In fact, as a Pew Poll revealed last month, it’s “almost universal.” But that’s no wonder considering that the benefits of Keystone XL are obvious.  As our pamphlet “Why Americans Say Yes to Keystone XL” explains, Keystone XL will create tens of thousands of [...]

Nothing New about “New” Keystone XL GHG study

There’s nothing new in this “new report” on Keystone XL and greenhouse gas emissions – the same researchers released a draft of this study in December 2013. The State Department took that draft report into account (citing it in its Final Environmental Impact Statement) and still concluded that Keystone XL would have a negligible impact [...]

The “New Evidence” On Why Obama Should Approve Keystone XL Now

While Americans today are enjoying the tremendous economic benefits of increased North American oil production, opponents of fossil fuels remain committed to their quest of keeping us dependent on sources of energy from unstable regions of the world. Today anti-Keystone XL activist groups such as Bold Nebraska, the Sierra Club and 350.org wrote yet another [...]

The Facts NBC Did NOT Tell You About Keystone XL

After nearly six years of review, the Keystone XL pipeline is perhaps the most studied pipeline in the world. It’s also likely the only pipeline that’s been consistently in the media spotlight. So it was very surprising to see a recent NBC news article, entitled “‘We Will Fight’: Keystone XL Pipeline Foes Fear Worst for [...]